Conundrum

[runnerhiker]

I think a summary of what you are thinking is: "peace of mind" is going to cost you money. The only question is, how much? You have decided not to go the most expensive way of buying a new 1250. The next level down on cost is buying a slightly used 1250. And the next level down on cost is buying an extended warranty or a maintenance contract. I think you also don't really want to keep the 1200 without warranty.

So, two choices. More cost gives you more peace of mind. Less cost gives you less peace of mind. Forget about the cost - how much peace of mind do you want? Answer that, and there is your answer.